The state of the protein bar aisle
We score 395 protein bars from 84 brands on one published formula. Here is what the whole aisle looks like when every bar is measured the same way. Every number on this page is computed from the live board and refreshes daily.
1. Most protein bars don't earn a good grade
Only 43 bars — 11% of the board — score 75 or higher. Nearly half (47%) land at D or F, usually for the same handful of reasons: too much sugar for the protein, a long list of additives, or cheap fats. The average bar scores 53, a C.
Where the A-grade bars sit
Plot every bar by protein per calorie and sugar, and the good ones cluster in one corner: 40 of the 43 bars graded A or A+ have at least 10 g of protein per 100 calories and no more than 5 g of sugar. Only 2 of the 184 D and F bars do.
- A or A+ (43)
- B or C (168)
- D or F (184)
Show as a table
| Grade | Bars | In the corner | Median protein / 100 cal | Median sugar |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A or A+ | 43 | 40 (93%) | 11.7 g | 1 g |
| B or C | 168 | 41 (24%) | 8.7 g | 2 g |
| D or F | 184 | 2 (1%) | 6.3 g | 6 g |
2. What's actually in the wrapper
The protein is usually fine. It's everything around it that separates a good bar from a candy bar. Palm oil and sugar alcohols are the norm rather than the exception, and more than a third of bars rely on artificial sweeteners.
3. The brand gap is enormous
Brand average scores range from 80 (David) to 33 (Power Crunch). Brand loyalty matters more than most shoppers think: picking the right brand moves you further than picking the right flavor.
- One bar
- Brand average
4. A “keto” label isn't a promise
6 of the 20 bars labeled keto carry more than 5 g of net carbs (total carbs minus fiber and sugar alcohols) by their own label numbers. The biggest gap: Elevation Snack Advance Bar Caramel Double Chocolate Crunch, at 17 g. That's why our keto list checks the math instead of trusting the wrapper.
5. Fiber numbers get padded
53 bars (13%) declare fiber we don't fully count, either because it comes from fiber syrups like IMO and soluble corn fiber (which digest more like sugar) or because the number is implausibly high for a whole-food bar. They declare 13.4 g on average; we count 5 g. See the high-fiber list for bars whose fiber is the real thing.
6. You mostly get what you pay for, with one big exception
Bars under $2 average 50; bars at $3 and up average 52. But the best value on the board breaks the pattern: Kirkland Signature Protein Bar (Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough) costs about $1.15 and scores 82 (A) — 18.3 g of protein per dollar.
7. One in seven is a candy bar in disguise
51 bars (13%) carry 15 g of sugar or more, or deliver less than 5 g of protein per 100 calories. Nothing wrong with a treat, but the protein on the front is doing a lot of marketing work. The worst offenders are on the best bars page, under “Candy bars in disguise.”
How these numbers are made
Every ranked bar is scored by the same published formula, from product-label data collected through Open Food Facts; where a barcode also appears in USDA FoodData Central, the two labels are cross-checked (see data & trust). Duplicate listings and mis-filed products are removed before anything is counted. The board grows daily, so these figures move.
Cite or share this report
Journalists, creators and researchers are welcome to use these figures with a link back to this page. Suggested citation:
The Barometer, "The state of the protein bar aisle" (2026), https://the-barometer.com/insights/ — data as of 2026-11-16.