Data & trust
A ranking is only as good as its numbers. Here's exactly where The Barometer's data comes from, how current it is, and how it stays honest.
Where the numbers come from
- Launch set (90 bars): the most popular bars, compiled by hand from product labels, official brand sites, and major nutrition databases, then spot-checked.
- Open Food Facts (391 bars): a scheduled job harvests the free, open Open Food Facts database daily — sweeping every protein-bar category and every brand we already track — then routes each new bar by data quality. Entries with a complete, plausible label (full nutrition panel and an ingredient list) are added to the board and flagged auto-imported; anything with gaps waits in the review queue, where an automated re-check promotes it the day its label becomes complete. That way a genuinely good bar is never missed just because it fell off a page — worst case, it sits near the top of the queue. Where possible, each import is also cross-checked by barcode against USDA FoodData Central — two independent sources agreeing marks a bar cross-verified; when they disagree, the USDA-published (manufacturer-submitted) label wins and the bar is corrected to match it.
- Community submissions (4 so far): anyone can submit a bar; each submission is checked automatically. Implausible numbers are rejected with an explanation; plausible ones wait in the review queue until Open Food Facts or USDA confirms the label (by barcode), and then rank on that public data. A self-reported label never reaches the board on its own.
How we keep it honest
- One published formula. Every score comes from the same weighted formula on the methodology page — nothing hand-tuned per bar.
- Auditable sources. Each bar links out to the sources its data came from (spanning 67+ sites) so you can check the label yourself.
- Photos are open-licensed. Product images come from Open Food Facts; bars without one get a generated placeholder rather than a scraped image.
- No pay-to-rank. Buy links may become affiliate links, but they never affect a bar's score, and that will always be stated.
Use the data
The whole dataset — every bar, every nutrition field, the ingredient flags and the computed scores — is a single structured file that refreshes daily. Apps, newsletters, researchers and retailers can license it (one-off export or a live feed). Brands can also commission a reformulation report: exactly which sub-scores hold a bar back and what label changes would move it up a grade. Get in touch via the submit form (mention “data”).
The honest caveats
This is a heuristic, not a lab assay. A few secondary fields on newer, direct-to-consumer bars are best-effort estimates where labels aren't published online — those bars are marked community-submitted / pending verification. Formulations and prices change constantly, so always confirm the label on the package you actually buy.