← Leaderboard

Nature Valley Nature Valley Protein Chewy Bar — Peanut Butter Dark Chocolate

Nature Valley Protein Chewy Bar

F38/ 100 health score · #320 of 395
Find on Amazon →Brand site
Compare prices: iHerb · Walmart · Target
Protein
10g
20% of calories
Protein density
5g
per 100 calories
Sugar
7g
5g added
Calories
200
per bar
Net carbs
9g
carbs − fiber − sugar alc.
Value
12.5g
protein per $ · $0.80/bar ($11.99 for 15)

Is Nature Valley Protein Chewy Bar healthy?

No

Is Nature Valley Protein Chewy Bar healthy? No: it's essentially a candy bar with some protein in it.

Nature Valley Protein Chewy Bar (Peanut Butter Dark Chocolate) scores 38/100 (grade F) on The Barometer's formula, ranking #320 of 395 bars. That's 10 g of protein for 200 calories (5 g per 100 cal), 7 g of sugar and 6 g of fiber.

  • Biggest strength: made with recognizable whole-food ingredients (roasted peanuts, peanut butter, no artificial flavors).
  • Biggest trade-off: low protein for the calories (5 g per 100 cal).
  • Also good: great value — 12.5 g of protein per dollar.
  • Also note: contains industrial seed oils.

Ranked higher — worth a look:

Why this score

✓ Strengths
  • Made with recognizable whole-food ingredients (roasted peanuts, peanut butter, no artificial flavors).
  • Great value — 12.5 g of protein per dollar.
⚠ Trade-offs
  • Low protein for the calories (5 g per 100 cal).
  • Contains industrial seed oils.
  • Contains corn/glucose syrup.

Score breakdown

Protein density ·24%0
Protein amount ·14%17
Sugar ·22%43
Ingredient quality ·22%66
Saturated fat ·9%56
Fiber ·9%75

Each sub-score is 0–100; the overall score is their weighted average. See the full methodology.

Nutrition facts

Serving size40 g
Calories200
Protein10 g
Total fat12 g
Saturated fat3.5 g
Cholesterol5 mg
Sodium160 mg
Total carbs15 g
Fiber6 g
Total sugar7 g
Added sugar5 g
Sugar alcohols—

Ingredients & profile

Not sure what something means? Ingredient glossary →

Protein source
peanut + soy protein isolate + whey concentrate

The good

✓ roasted peanuts✓ peanut butter✓ no artificial flavors

Watch-outs

⚠ seed oils⚠ canola oil⚠ corn syrup⚠ fructose

Sweeteners

sugarcorn syrupfructose

Dietary

gluten-free

Allergens

peanutsoymilk

Head to head

Compare Nature Valley Protein Chewy Bar with David Protein Bar (#1) → or any other bar in the interactive comparison.

On the best-of lists

Qualifies for these lists, but outside the top 10:

What would move it up a grade?

The formula is public, so we can run label changes through it and show exactly what each would do to the score. Hypothetical — computed, not tested recipes.

F 38
→Cut 5 g of sugar +13
=D 51
Cut 5 g of sugar
Same bar with 5 g less sugar (about 20 fewer calories).
+13 → 51
Add 5 g of protein
5 g more protein in the same bar (+20 calories).
+11 → 49
Remove the seed oils
Use nut butter, cocoa butter or coconut oil instead of soybean / canola / sunflower oil.
+3 → 41
Cut the corn / glucose syrup
Bind with dates, nut butter or allulose syrup instead.
+2 → 40

Make this bar? We put together full reformulation reports — every lever, the trade-offs between them, and how you'd rank against competitors after the change. Get in touch →

Data source: seed · naturevalley.com, world.openfoodfacts.org · last updated 2026-07-18

Formulations change — always confirm the label on the package you buy. Prices are approximate US retail and fluctuate.