← Leaderboard · All matchups

Head to head

Quest Protein Bar vs Kirkland Signature Protein Bar Cookies and Cream

Quest Protein Bar wins. It scores 82 to 78 on The Barometer's health formula and takes 6 of the 11 categories with a clear result.

  • Kirkland Signature Protein Bar Cookies and Cream is actually leaner (12.9 vs 10.5 g protein per 100 cal), but loses elsewhere.
  • Cleaner label: Quest Protein Bar scores 75/100 on ingredient quality vs 43.
MetricQuest Protein BarKirkland Signature Protein Bar Cookies and Cream
Health scoreA82A78
Protein20 g22 g
Protein / 100 cal10.5 g12.9 g
% cals from protein42%52%
Calories190170
Total sugar1 g2 g
Added sugar0 g2 g
Net carbs3 g13 g
Fiber11 g11 g
Saturated fat2.5 g2 g
Sodium220 mg180 mg
Price / serving$2.25—
Protein per $8.9 g—
Seed oilsNoYes
Ingredient quality75 / 10043 / 100
Flagged ingredientssucralosesunflower oil

Greener cell wins the row. Calories aren't scored as better or worse — it depends on your goal. Both bars are scored by the same published formula; nothing here is sponsored.

Swap in a different bar →