← Leaderboard · All matchups

Head to head

Kirkland Signature Protein Bar vs David Cake Batter Flavored Bar

Kirkland Signature Protein Bar wins. It scores 82 to 77 on The Barometer's health formula and takes 3 of the 10 categories with a clear result.

  • David Cake Batter Flavored Bar is actually leaner (18.7 vs 11.1 g protein per 100 cal), but loses elsewhere.
  • Cleaner label: Kirkland Signature Protein Bar scores 67/100 on ingredient quality vs 46.
MetricKirkland Signature Protein BarDavid Cake Batter Flavored Bar
Health scoreA82A77
Protein21 g28 g
Protein / 100 cal11.1 g18.7 g
% cals from protein44%75%
Calories190150
Total sugar1 g0 g
Added sugar0 g0 g
Net carbs13 g12 g
Fiber10 g0 g
Saturated fat2.5 g1.5 g
Sodium190 mg105 mg
Price / serving$1.15—
Protein per $18.3 g—
Seed oilsNoNo
Ingredient quality67 / 10046 / 100
Flagged ingredientspalm kernel oil, sucralosepalm kernel, artificial flavor

Greener cell wins the row. Calories aren't scored as better or worse — it depends on your goal. Both bars are scored by the same published formula; nothing here is sponsored.

Swap in a different bar →